enso brands logo

How to Reclaim a Lost Amazon Buy Box

amazon buy box

How to Reclaim a Lost Amazon Buy Box

If you’re selling on Amazon, you know how important the Buy Box is for your business. It’s the holy grail of visibility and conversions on the platform. But winning it isn’t easy, and losing it can really hurt your sales. In this detailed guide, we’ll dive into why your product might lose the Buy Box and, most importantly, give you practical steps to win it back.



Unlock Your Amazon Success Today with Our Flat Fee Expert Services!

Select the plan that best suits your needs and begin your journey today.

What Is the Buy Box?


How to Reclaim a Lost Amazon Buy Box


The Buy Box is a prominent feature located on the right-hand side of an Amazon product detail page. It serves as a call-to-action section, displaying buttons like “Add to Cart” or “Buy Now.” Its purpose is to provide customers with a convenient way to immediately start the purchasing process and quickly proceed to the checkout page. Keep in mind, that only one seller selling the same product under the same product category is allowed to win the Buy Box at any given time.


It’s worth noting that not all sellers are Buy Box eligible. You need to have a professional seller account and prove you’re better than your competition.


Also, if you win the Buy Box and you’re the sole brand owner of the product, you don’t control the entire product detail page. There might still be other sellers listed below as “Other Sellers on Amazon.” However, winning it significantly boosts your chances of making a sale, as it is the default choice for most customers.


Why Is Winning the Buy Box So Important?



Winning the Buy Box offers several advantages that can significantly impact your sales and overall success as an Amazon seller. Here are the key benefits:


1) Increases Visibility and Conversion Rates


Winning the Buy Box for your product on Amazon means getting your item in front of millions of customers. But that’s not all. When customers see the Buy Box, they’re more inclined to trust it and make a purchase right then and there. That means better chances of turning those views into sales.


2) Reduces Competition


When you win the Buy Box on Amazon, it means customers can only buy from you by default. This special status cuts down on competition and makes it more likely for you to make sales without losing customers to other sellers.


3) Improves Trust and Credibility


Amazon gives out the Buy Box to sellers who have good performance records, like fast shipping and positive customer feedback. When you win it, it tells customers that Amazon believes in your service and product quality. This stamp of approval boosts your credibility with shoppers, which means more sales for you.


4) Gives You a Competitive Advantage


Winning the Buy Box gives you a big advantage over other sellers who sell the same product. Customers usually pick products from the Buy Box, even if there are other listings for the same item. This advantage is super important on Amazon where competition is fierce.


amazon buy box

Can You Lose the Buy Box Once You’ve Won It?


Winning the Buy Box on Amazon is a big deal for any seller. It’s a clear recognition of your pricing, service quality, and overall performance. However, winning it does not guarantee permanent ownership, and it is indeed possible to lose it along the way due to several reasons.



Reasons for a Lost Buy Box



The Buy Box on Amazon is a highly competitive space, and losing it can have a significant impact on your sales and visibility as a seller. To regain it, it’s important to understand the reasons why you lost it in the first place. Let’s explore the key reasons why your product may lose the Buy Box:


1) You’ve Priced Your Products Too High


From the start, Amazon’s main aim has been to offer top-quality products that you might not find anywhere else, all at the best prices. If the Buy Box Algorithm detects the same product being sold cheaper elsewhere compared to your listed price, you’ll lose your Buy Box. For instance, if you’re selling hair ties for $5 and someone else is selling an identical one for $2, then you’ll lose your Buy Box.


Also, if you have frequent price fluctuations or inconsistent pricing practices, you may lose the Buy Box (this is one of the main causes for private label sellers losing their Buy Box).


2) You Have Insufficient Inventory Levels


One of the main reasons Amazon became so popular so fast, compared to other e-commerce platforms was because of its fast shipping speeds and it’s not about to give up that reputation.


Winning the Buy Box can lead to more sales because more customers want to buy your product. This can make it a bit difficult to guess how much stock to maintain. But, if running out of stock means customers can’t get their products on time, sellers with available stock will get priority, leading to you losing your Buy Box.


3) Your Products Are Not Eligible for Amazon Prime


Just because you’re an FBA seller and products are eligible for Prime doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed to win (and keep) the Buy Box, but it does improve your chances considering that Amazon prioritizes fast shipping speed and high quality. If you’ve switched to a different fulfillment method, like a third-party logistics provider, and your Buy Box disappeared, not being Prime-eligible might be part of the reason. 


4) There’s New Competition on Your Listing


When another seller joins your listing, it can cause you to lose the Buy Box. If this new seller offers the same item at a lower price, they may secure the Buy Box instead. This is often called “hijacking,” and it can be a tough situation to deal with, especially with products you’ve worked hard to establish, like private-label items.


5) Poor Performance or Slow Delivery


Finally, losing the Buy Box can happen because of frequent order mistakes, slow deliveries, or negative customer reviews. Amazon emphasizes customer satisfaction, so sellers who consistently offer great service stand a better chance of securing and keeping the Buy Box.


How to Regain a Lost Buy Box


Since Buy Box winners switch about every 15 minutes on average, it’s crucial to do everything you can to keep your position or reclaim it. Here are some handy tips and tricks to help you out:


1) Set a Competitive Price


Losing the Buy Box can happen when your prices are higher than your competitors. To get it back, check what your competition is charging, both on and off Amazon. If Amazon sees that none of the sellers are offering a competitive price compared to other websites, they might suppress the Buy Box altogether. Don’t forget to factor in expenses like shipping costs. Remember you don’t need to have the lowest price but you need to have a price that’s on par with your competitors.


To avoid getting into constant price wars, consider using automated repricing tools.


2) Maintain Consistent Inventory Levels


To increase your chances of regaining the Buy Box, it’s essential to maintain consistent inventory levels. Take proactive steps to avoid stockouts and ensure your products are readily available. Use inventory forecasting tools and Amazon’s Inventory Performance Index (IPI) to optimize stock levels, prevent shortages, and guarantee a steady supply of your products.


3) Provide Exceptional Customer Service


A happy customer plays a key role in getting the Buy Box back. Focus on providing excellent support to your customers, promptly addressing their concerns, and always trying to go above and beyond what they expect. When you get positive feedback and good ratings because of your great service, you boost your chances of reclaiming the Buy Box.


4) Combat Fake Sellers and Counterfeits


If you lose the Buy Box because of unauthorized sellers or counterfeit products, you need to act fast. Start by sending a ‘Cease and Desist’ letter directly to the unauthorized seller, stating your rights and demanding that they stop selling your products.


If that doesn’t work, the next step is to contact Amazon’s Seller Support team. Give them all the details they need, including evidence of the unauthorized sellers and any other information that can support your case.


5) Consider Using FBA


Consider using FBA if you haven’t already. A lot of sellers lose their spot in the Buy Box due to a change in their fulfillment service or the absence of FBA altogether. In fact, according to research, FBA sellers have a 45% higher chance of winning the Buy Box.


With FBA, Amazon takes care of shipping, handling, and customer service for you. Plus, FBA makes your products eligible for Prime, which means fast delivery for customers. While there are other ways to qualify for Prime, such as Seller Fulfilled Prime, not all sellers meet the criteria for this program. Only sellers with an outstanding Amazon sales record are eligible for it.


6) Additional Strategies


In addition to the tips above, consider doing the following:


Optimize your product title, bullet points, and description with the latest keywords. Also, make sure they don’t violate any Amazon policies.


– If your seller performance metrics like on-time shipment rate, order defect rate, and customer feedback rating have dropped, make sure to improve them.


– Consider using promotional programs like Deal of the Day or Lightning Deals to increase visibility and sales. Also, consider using PPC campaigns.


How to Effectively Delete and Relist Your Product to Regain a Lost Buy Box


If you find yourself unable to regain your lost Buy Box despite pricing your product correctly and implementing the above strategies, you might have to consider deleting and relisting the ASIN. Here’s how to do it:




What is the difference between winning the Buy Box and simply being listed as a seller on Amazon?


Winning the Buy Box means that your product is featured prominently on the product detail page with the option for customers to add it directly to their cart or buy it with one click. Being listed as a seller without winning the Buy Box means your product is still available, but customers need to click on “See All Buying Options” to place an order.



Can I win the Buy Box if I’m a new seller on Amazon?


Yes, it’s possible, but winning the Buy Box typically requires a track record of good performance. New sellers may need some time to establish this track record before consistently winning the Buy Box.



How often does the Buy Box change?


The Buy Box winners can change frequently, sometimes as often as every 15 minutes.





Winning and retaining the Buy Box on Amazon takes careful planning and constant improvement. While there’s no Buy Box cheat sheet for success, following the tips in this guide can help you increase your chances.


Looking for expert assistance in managing your Amazon seller account? Enso Brands offers a comprehensive range of one-stop Amazon services tailored to optimize your performance and maximize your potential on the platform. Contact us today and discover how we can help your business thrive on Amazon!

40 Pages of Amazon Ultimate listing and Design Templates

Transform Your Amazon Presence: Unlock Sales and Dominate with Our Ultimate Listing and Design Templates!

  • Expert advice and insider tips on creating a perfect Amazon listing​
  • Product Insert Template
  • Product Packaging Template
  • Amazon Posts Template

About The Author:

Table of Contents

40 Pages of Amazon Ultimate listing and Design Templates

Transform Your Amazon Presence: Unlock Sales and Dominate with Our Ultimate Listing and Design Templates!

Download Free

40 Pages of Amazon Ultimate listing and Design Templates

Transform Your Amazon Presence: Unlock Sales and Dominate with Our Ultimate Listing and Design Templates!

  • Expert advice and insider tips on creating a perfect Amazon listing​
  • Product Insert Template
  • Product Packaging Template
  • Amazon Posts Template